www.reviewthis.com

The 10 Best Eyeliner Pencils of 2019

The 10 Best Eyeliner Pencils of 2019

Everyone who wears makeup knows that eyeliner is an important part of your daily routine. Therefore, you want to be sure that you are getting the best eyeliner pencil you can to complete your makeup.

With so many options available on the market, how do you know you are getting the right eyeliner pencil for you?

That is a great question because there really are many different types available. You can narrow down your search by knowing what look you want to achieve. Many eyeliner pencils can give thin, gentle lines to bold and intense marks that are perfect for any occasion.

Whichever is your preference for eyeliner, you want to choose the one that will glide on smoothly, stay put when you need it to and sharpen to the right point.

To help you narrow down your choices amongst many different types of eyeliner pencils out there, we have rounded up the top ten best eyeliner pencils. Here you can review the best eyeliner pencils of 2019 and pick out the one that suits you and your eyes best.

The Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil with Sharpener - All Day Smudgeproof Wear - Easy to Use & Perfect Eye Liner for Your Cat Eyes & Waterline is an immovable eyeliner that is designed not to smudge, budge or run. You will love how easily this eyeliner goes on and how easy it is to get the perfect look you are wanting. You do not need to worry about rubbing your eyeliner off or having to worry about it running off.

This eyeliner is amazing for many different reasons, one of which is that you can achieve any dimension of style you want. You can get both thick and thin lines to give you any look you want from cat eyes to smoky eyes. You can even apply nice lines on your inner eyelid rim that will stay for a while. However, they won’t stay for the full day.

Overall, the Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil with Sharpener is one of the best eyeliners pencils because it is very versatile. Additionally, you don’t need to worry about reapplying or fixing smudges constantly as this eyeliner is infallible. You will find that you will not need any other eyeliner when you have this one.

Key Features
  • This eyeliner is infalliable, it does not smudge or run
  • With easy application, you can draw wings or achieve smoky eyes with little effort
  • Completely waterproof and will not run in any kind of moisture
Specifications
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Wear Time: 24 hours
  • Product Form: Pencil
  • Weight: 0.64 oz
Pros
  • Comes with a sharpener so that you don't have to fight with an incompatible one
  • Very smooth lines that can be thick or thin depending on your desire
  • Simple to apply and work with
Cons
  • Difficult to wash off
  • Does not last on your inner eyelid rim very well

The Le Crayon Khol Eyeliner Eye Pencil Liner, 602 Black Ebony, Full Size  is among the best eyeliner pencils because of how smooth it glides on and how precise the lines are. You will sincerely enjoy how this pencil does not require hard pressing when trying to outline your eyes. The pencil is strong, and the pigment lasts a while. However, if you need to sharpen it after time, you may have trouble getting the point.

The final product is that you will have eyes that look amazing and contoured perfectly. Any lines you are attempting from wings to double lines can be achieved easily because of how smooth this liner goes on. Even if you are a beginner, you can use this eyeliner pencil as it is designed to require little effort and expertise.

Overall, the Le Crayon Khol Eyeliner Eye Pencil Liner, 602 Black Ebony, Full Size  is a great eyeliner for those who want to quickly do their makeup with precision and accuracy. You can achieve anything from simple lines to smoky eyes using this liner without the need to practice for hours. However, be aware that you may have to wipe smudges out from under your eyes occasionally throughout the day.

Key Features
  • Has a creamy smooth line that makes it perfect for the smokey eye look
  • This pencil can contour and outline your eyes with precision making it ideal for beginners
  • Formulated to go on smooth and blend easily
Specifications
  • Waterproof: No
  • Wear Time: Several hours
  • Product Form: Pencil
  • Weight: 0.6 oz
Pros
  • Glides on smoothly
  • Does not wear down quickly
  • Excellent for precise lines
Cons
  • Needs to be reapplied through the day
  • If not careful it can leave smudge marks under your eyes
  • Breaks easily when sharpening

The Eye Liner Pencil Set - 12 Assorted Colors Natural Matte Long Lasting Hypoallergenic Eyeliners Eye Makeup Soft Crayon Pencils by Wonder X is a set of beautifully colored eyeliner pencils that are perfect for any occasion and with any outfit. You will love how big and dramatic your eyes will look. This eyeliner will go on smoothly, making it very easy to apply. You will sincerely enjoy how effortless this eyeliner is to outline your eyes.

The formula is designed to be lightweight, and it is creamy for easy application. The formula is also designed to stay true so that it won’t bleed or wear off over time. You will be able to enjoy the colors that will not smudge. Furthermore, this eyeliner is hypoallergenic so that even if you have sensitive skin, you won’t have any issues.

Overall, the Eye Liner Pencil Set is among the best eyeliner pencils you can get because these pencils are non-toxic and give you beautiful voluminous eyes that you will love. If you want big eyes and beautiful colors to play around with, you get that with these pencils. The only real drawback is that sharpening can be a pain as it can splinter the wood. However, that is a small thing for all the benefits.

Key Features
  • This set gives you pure and natural colors that look vibrant
  • Using these pencils, you can quickly achieve a dramatic effect
  • Applies smoothly providing you with either thick or thin lines according to your preference
Specifications
  • Waterproof: No
  • Wear Time: 12 hours
  • Product Form: Pencil
  • Weight: 2.4 oz
Pros
  • Glides on seamlessly
  • Beautiful colors that are bright and vibrant
  • Does not wear off easily
Cons
  • Is prone to smudging
  • Can be difficult to sharpen as the wood will splinter some

The Pierre Cardin Paris Longlasting Eyeliner Wooden Pencil, Moonlight, 0.01 oz is a great eyeliner pencil as it is designed to be compatible with any skin type without causing reactions. The formula is filled with natural oils and a variety of preservatives to help keep it from getting stale. You will love that this eyeliner does not need to be reapplied all the time as you can put it on in the morning and it will last until the end of the day.

The final looks you can achieve with this eyeliner are limitless. You can get smoky eyes, simple, clean lines, and even double lines or wings. The results are incomparable. However, be aware that if you put the liner on very close to the lid, you may end up having to deal with smudges that can be annoying.

Overall, the Pierre Cardin Paris Longlasting Eyeliner Wooden Pencil, Moonlight, 0.01 oz is a great liner that works well and stays a long time. Though it is not waterproof, it does have many other excellent qualities from how easy it is to sharpen to how smooth the lines are. You will sincerely enjoy this liner and make it a crucial part of your daily makeup routine.

Key Features
  • Made with soft wood and provides you high coverage
  • You'll get precise lines and rich color that has the right skin compatibility
  • Formulated with minerals and perservatives to last a long time
Specifications
  • Waterproof: No
  • Wear Time: 10 hours
  • Product Form: Wooden Pencil
  • Weight: 1.1 oz
Pros
  • Does not react badly with your skin
  • Goes on easily
  • Lasts most of the day
Cons
  • This eyeliener does smudge at times if not careful
  • Not waterproof and will run in rain

The INIKA Certified Organic Eye Pencil, All Natural Eyeliner, Vegan Eyeliner is an excellent eyeliner for those who have sensitive eyes. Formulated with 100 percent organic materials, this eyeliner will not hurt your eyes because it does not contain harsh chemicals. The payoff is that you will get nice clean lines that are nourishing for your skin and not going to harm your eyes.

The ingredients used to develop this eyeliner are crafted from plants and natural ingredients that include mineral pigments. You will be able to get intense color that goes on smoothly and looks intense all day long. You may even be able to wear this makeup for more than one day with only simple touch-ups because it has that kind of long-lasting wear.

Overall, the INIKA Certified Organic Eye Pencil, All Natural Eyeliner, Vegan Eyeliner is one of the best eyeliner pencils on the market because you get intense color, beautiful lines, and long-lasting wear. The only real drawback is that when it's new, it can be a bit rough to get started so you may want to test it on your hand before your eyes. However, once you get it smoothed out, you will love the no-smudging beautiful lined eyes.

Key Features
  • This eyeliner was formulated to include coconut oil so that it is soft and nourishing
  • Gives you nice creamy lines that are enhancing
  • Excellent eyeliner for those who have sensitive eyes
Specifications
  • Waterproof: No
  • Wear Time: All Day
  • Product Form: Pencil
  • Weight: 0.3 oz
Pros
  • Lasts as long as it says it will and sometimes longer
  • Does not smudge
  • Goes on smoothly and accurately
Cons
  • Rough upon intitial use
  • Pencil can splinter when you sharpen it

For a good waterproof eyeliner, you will love the Maybelline New York Tattoostudio Waterproof, Long Wearing, Eyeliner Pencil Makeup. This eyeliner is designed to go on with beautiful thick strokes that provide you amazing color. You will sincerely enjoy how intense your eyes will look and how beautifully they will stand out. You will be able to seamlessly create any look you want from cat eyes to wings.

This eyeliner lasts for up to 36 hours without the need to touch it up or reapply. This sharpen-able liner will give beautiful pigment-rich hues that deliver precise definition. Since this eyeliner comes in eight different colors you will be able to enjoy the beauty from a bright white all the way to the classic black. Every color is just as brilliant as the other.

Overall, the Maybelline New York Tattoostudio Waterproof, Long Wearing, Eyeliner Pencil Makeup is an excellent eyeliner that does not smudge or fade. Additionally, it is sebum resistant. Therefore, it can be very difficult to clean off. It does provide thick lines, so if you are more on the finer side, you may not want this eyeliner. However, for intensity and precise outlines, this is the eyeliner for you.

Key Features
  • This pencil gives you ultra-precise lines that have tattoo intensity
  • Glides on in only one stroke that is smooth and looks amazing
  • You can effortlessly define your eyes and have it last all day long
Specifications
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Wear Time: 36 hours
  • Product Form: Pencil
  • Weight: 0.32 oz
Pros
  • Really does last a long time
  • Nice and smooth lines that your can shape into anything
  • Completely waterproof
Cons
  • Very difficult to wash off
  • Gives very thick lines that may not appeal to you

The Covergirl Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil is a fun eyeliner pencil to work with. You will sincerely have a good time playing around with the different looks you can achieve using this pencil. The lines can be deep and intense if you desire them to be depending on the look you want to achieve. You can get nice smoky eyes and beautiful wings. Regardless of what look you want, this pencil can help you do it with ease.

Covergirl is known for providing quality products, and they don’t disappoint with this eyeliner pencil. However, you need to aware that it is not waterproof and may need some reapplication throughout the day, but it is a minor inconvenience.

Overall, the Covergirl Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil is one of the best eyeliner pencils because it delivers on both precision and versatility. You can do just about anything with this pencil as it can create any line you want without giving you raccoon eyes. The blender tip is a bonus for when you want to have soft smudges that will make your eyes stand out.

Key Features
  • A nice gliding eyeliner pencil that comes with a blending tip
  • You can use this eyeliner pencil for any look as it is very versatile
  • You will get the right shade for any occasion you are looking forward to
  • Comes in a pack of 2
Specifications
  • Waterproof: No
  • Wear Time: 12 hours
  • Product Form: Pencil
  • Weight: 0.64 oz
Pros
  • Goes on easily
  • It is a very easy pencil to work with when experimenting with designs
  • Has s smudging tool that is fun to work with
Cons
  • This eyeliner is not waterproof and it will run
  • Needs to reapplied throughout the day here and there due to smudging

The L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner is an amazing eyeliner pencil that is great for all experience levels. You will be able to take your day look and turn it into a night out without having to redo all your makeup. You will love how rich and intense this kajal liner is and how it delivers incredible definition. Using this eyeliner you can easily experiment with different looks as it is so simple to work with.

The unique tip makes it very easy to apply. Whether you want a thin line or a bold, thick line, both can be achieved with this liner. A bonus is this eyeliner pencil comes with a sharpener that is designed for this pencil. You won’t have to worry about splintering or broken leads.

Overall, the L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner is one of the best eyeliner pencils you can get today because of how versatile it is to use daily. You will sincerely enjoy the fact that you can use this pencil for work and your night out on the town. Either way, you will be able to accentuate your eyes with exact precision.

Key Features
  • Developed with a dark formula that delivers deep, intense lines
  • You will get amazing and stunning definition that is applied seamlessly
  • Get the exact look you desire using this smudge proof makeup that will last all day long
Specifications
  • Waterproof: No
  • Wear Time: 24 hours
  • Product Form: Pencil
  • Weight: 0.8 oz
Pros
  • Glides on very easily
  • Allows you to experiment with different looks
  • Does not smudge easily
Cons
  • Is not waterproof so it will run when exposed to moisture
  • Needs to be reapplied throughout the day, especially in humid conditions

Using this eyeliner pencil you can create any look you desire. The L'Oréal Paris Makeup Infallible Never Fail Pencil Eyeliner is designed to give you the exact lines you are looking for when doing your makeup. This pencil will glide easily over your lids and will not fade all day long. You will love that this makeup is designed to give you amazing looking eyes from morning til night without smudging.

However, if you want to smudge it to give yourself smoky eyes, you can use the built-in smudger. Furthermore, there is a built-in sharpener that also helps you get the tip you desire without having to struggle. Additionally, there are seven different shades you can get to suit your preferences.

Overall, the L'Oréal Paris Makeup Infallible Never Fail Pencil Eyeliner is one of the best eyeliner pencils you can get because of how versatile it is to work with. However, if you mess up with the application even a little, it is difficult to wash off. Initially, you may find it rough, but it will soften fairly quickly to give you those smooth, creamy lines that are both bold and intense.

Key Features
  • Formulated to not smudge or wear off throughout the day
  • Glides easily over your eyelids and gives you bold lines
  • Has a smudger that allows you to create the look you desire
Specifications
  • Waterproof: No
  • Wear Time: 16 hours
  • Product Form: Pencil
  • Weight: 0.32 oz
Pros
  • Comes with a built-in sharpener
  • Goes on very easily
  • Lasts all day long without needing touch-ups
Cons
  • Very difficult to wash off
  • Needs a bit of softening before using

The Maybelline Line Express Sharpenable Wood Pencil with Built-In Blending Smudger Tip Creamy Liner Eyeliner Eye Makeup, Ebony Black is one of the best eyeliner pencils because it is designed to give you a look you want and how you want it. Using the smudging tool, you can contour your liner into wings, smoky eye, and even cat-eye. Regardless of what you are hoping to achieve, it can be done with this eyeliner as it is versatile.

This eyeliner is creamy and allows you to glide it over your eyes without much effort. Furthermore, since it is ophthalmologist tested, you won’t have to worry about sensitive eyes reacting to this liner. You can wear this eyeliner all day long without worry about it wearing off, though it will smudge at times. However, it does come in three different shades to give you options.

Overall, the Maybelline Line Express Sharpenable Wood Pencil with Built-In Blending Smudger Tip is among the best eyeliner pencils because of how versatile and easy it is to use daily. You can put it on for work in the morning and add to it in the evening to get a more intense “going out” look. It's nice eyeliner for whatever look you want to have.

Key Features
  • Get a creamy application that can go from smooth to intense according to what you want
  • There is a built-in smudging tool that helps you with contouring
  • Comes in three color intense shades that will give you whatever look you want
Specifications
  • Waterproof: No
  • Wear Time: 12 hours
  • Product Form: Pencil
  • Weight: 0.035 oz
Pros
  • Glides on easily
  • Contouring smudging tool works very well
  • Washes off without much effort
Cons
  • Does smudge easy enough
  • Must be reapplied throughout the day as it does not last the full 12 hours

Picking the right eyeliner is a challenge when you aren’t sure how it will look when you apply it to your eyes. There are a few things you want to consider when its comes to picking your eyeliner pencil.

What should you consider when choosing an eyeliner pencil?

To get the right pencil for you, you should think about a few things first.

Style/Look

Choosing the right eyeliner pencil is going to be one that will allow you to achieve the style and look you are aiming for. If you want to be able to get a beautiful smoky eye or have bold wings, you want to be sure that your pencil will achieve those looks.

If you change your look or style day to day, you also want to be sure to get an eyeliner pencil that is versatile and can give you what you want to for work and what you want for play.

Experience Level

If you aren’t very experienced when it comes to applying eyeliner, you want a pencil that will help you achieve seamless lines with little to no effort. Be sure to choose a pencil that is easy to wash off because you don’t want to have red eyes from having to scrub repeatedly.

When you are more experienced, you can work with an eyeliner pencil that is more complicated to apply or that has special tools such as a smudging or contouring tool. You can also work with a waterproof eyeliner or smudge-proof because you won’t worry about messing up and struggling to wash.

Day to Day

Another decision that needs to be made before you make a final eyeliner pencil choice is what does your day look like? If you are the type that goes from work to the club at night, you want your eyeliner to be buildable to go from the smooth elegant look for work to the intense bold look for the club. There are plenty of eyeliner pencils that can give you both thin and thick lines.

Additionally, think about if you are going to be in and out of the elements all day. If you are, choosing one that is smudge-proof and waterproof. You don’t want to have to go out and visit a client or meet friends and have your eyeliner complete smudged around your eyes.

The Bottom Line

When choosing the best eyeliner pencil for your needs, make sure you have considered everything you want from your eyeliner. Eyeliner can make or break your overall look, so you want to make sure you are choosing the right one for you and your lifestyle, and that you take proper care of your eyeliner pencil so it lasts.

Resources — Makeup, StyleCaster

Share this Buyers Guide