www.reviewthis.com

The 10 Best Eyeshadows of 2019

Eyeshadows: The Best of 2019

If your eyes are windows to the soul, then eyeshadow might count as the curtains. And just as with curtains, you could have something sheer and neutral, or dark and mysterious, or colorful and cheerful.

The trick is to find the best eyeshadow for your needs. These days, there's a lot from which to choose, whether it's a small palette of neutral colors that complement your skin tone, a few shades to create the perfect smoky eye, or a giant booklet of a rainbow of colors to craft an awesome look for your next party. You can find powders, creams, and even super-safe and vegan formulations.

Take a look at our picks for the best eyeshadows. Whatever look you're going for, you are sure to find a product that fits your needs.

Ever wish you had the same amount of colors and textures of the best eyeshadow similar to that of a professional makeup artist? Well, turns out, you totally can! Thanks to this 2-pack eyeshadow deal, you get a whopping 36 gorgeous shades (18 shades per palette) of varying colors, intensities, textures and finishes, worthy of being in any makeup artist’s collection.

Let’s start with the Twilight Dust palette. This impressive book contains 18 stunning hues perfect for dramatic looks. First off, the palette includes one metallic glitter texture, perfect for taking regular looks up a notch. The palette also boasts 10 highly pigmented matte shades, great for creating velvety smoky eyes. The matte shades go on like butter, making them great for blending. Lastly, the palette features 7 pressed pearl hues that give your lids an amazingly pretty sheen. When you combine all these different textures, you’re left with incredibly unique, dynamic looks!

You’ll also love the accompanying Aromas Nude palette. This palette, while high in quality like its sister product, contains a whole new array of colors. This booklet contains 10 highly pigmented eyeshadows that contain aloe vera and coconut oil, allowing them to go on buttery smooth. The palette also contains 4 reflective shades full of sparkling flecks, ideal for duo-chromatic looks.

Both palettes contain powder shadow designed to wear all day and night — it’s even cruelty-free and waterproof! This is seriously some of the best eyeshadow you can come across online.

Key Features
  • Set of 2 18-Shade Palettes
  • Mix of glitter, matte, pearl, and shimmer finishes
  • Cruelty-free, lightweight formula
  • Highly pigmented shades
  • Long-lasting, waterproof
Specifications
  • No. of Colors: 18 + 18
  • Dimensions: 7.5 x 4.3 x 1.1 inches
  • Product Form: Powder
  • Waterproof: Yes
Pros
  • Goes on smooth and creamy
  • Different textures provide wide array of looks
  • Massive collection of shades
Cons
  • Colors could blend a little more smoothly
  • Glitter scatters when using certain shades
  • Has an off-putting smell upon opening

If you wear makeup at all, you know how important having the basics are. So the best eyeshadow palette you can acquire consists of plenty of matte nudes and earth tones. And when it comes to everyday, neutral colors, the Japonesque Velvet Touch Shadow Palette makes a great addition to your makeup collection.

When it comes to a basic, everyday looks, this palette provides you with everything you’d possibly need: deep, rich matte shadows along with creamy, light matte shades to compliment them. But while these make for great daytime colors, the palette can also be used to achieve more vibrant, eye-catching looks.

These eyeshadows are designed to be incredibly long-lasting, so you won’t need to reapply again and again throughout the day. The shadows’ compact case is also great for toting around in your purse or backpack, should you need to do your makeup on-the-go.

These rich neutral tones are great for achieving soft, smokey eyes and beautifully blended looks. But along with being the best eyeshadow for your favorite makeup styles, these perfectly dark tones are fantastic to use on other parts of your face as well. If you use the right brush, these shadows prove to be infinitely versatile. With the right brush, you can use the browner shades to fill in your eyebrows and can even use them for eyeliner. And if you add a little water to your brush, you can enjoy a thicker, richer version of the deep earth tone hues.

Key Features
  • Ultra light, silky formula
  • Reistant to creasing
  • 8 matte shadows
Specifications
  • No. of Colors: 8
  • Dimensions: 6.8 x 0.7 x 3.7 inches
  • Product Form: Powder
  • Waterproof: No
Pros
  • Perfect for subtle and dramatic looks
  • Great blendability
  • Can also be used to fill in eyebrows
Cons
  • Colors are a little dark
  • Doesn't include mirror or application brush

If you love fun, vibrant color, this creme eyeshadow by Revlon offers some of the best eyeshadow you could find online. Not only does the eyeshadow go on as smooth as butter, it comes in an amazing 12 different colors, all richly pigmented and gorgeous.

Instead of buying a massive palette full of eyeshadows you’ll never wear, these creme shadows come individually packaged, so you can choose the best eyeshadows for you without getting stuck with ones you’ll literally never wear. And while these shadows are super buttery and creamy, they won’t get lost in the creases of your lids. They’re specifically designed to last up to 24 hours. That’s right, by the end of the day, your eyes should look exactly the same as they did when you first applied it. Amazing, right?

Another great feature of this eyeshadow is its undeniable portability. Each eyeshadow pot comes with a built-in application brush that’s small enough to provide gorgeous color to your lids and deep corners of your eyes. And since the creamy shadow comes in an easy-access pot, you can use skinny brushes you already have to make unique designs and can even use it as eyeliner.

The Revlon Colorstay Eyeshadows have plenty of different finishes and sheens, perfect for just about any look you could think of. From velvety “black currant” and “cognac” to light and airy “vanilla” and “earl gray” — there’s no way you’ll find a color that doesn’t suit you. Just beware, after checking out all these colors, you’ll likely want to get all of them!

Key Features
  • Up to 24-hour staying power
  • Built-in application brush
  • Waterproof formula
  • 12 available shades
Specifications
  • No. of Colors: 12
  • Dimensions: 1 x 1.6 x 1.6 inches
  • Product Form: Cream
  • Waterproof: Yes
Pros
  • Smooth, creamy texture
  • Can make matte, metallic, and sparkly looks
  • Boasts color-stay technology
  • Included brush makes the eyeshadow super-portable
Cons
  • Small brush can be hard to hold
  • Not the best for subtle looks

Whether it’s a sultry smokey eye or a sweet minimal look you’re going for, you can be sure you’ll find it in this Lamora Beauty Makeup Palette! With an impressive 16 colors to choose from, there’s truly no look you can’t achieve when you have this palette in your beauty arsenal.

This palette contains both shimmery and metallic hues along with colors that have more of a matte finish. But no matter the type of hue it is, each color is intensely pigmented to give you that perfect pop of color you’ve always tried to achieve. The shadows are also designed to be blended, helping you get the most dynamic looks ever, all from one place.

While the wide array of colors are, of course, a huge stand-out with this palette, the makeup’s unique formula is also quite desirable. All of Lamora Beauty’s makeup is cruelty-free and 100 percent vegan, so you can be sure no animals were harmed in the making of the product. The eyeshadows are also ultra-micronized, deeply pigmented and waterproof. And while the makeup is in powder form, it goes on incredibly smooth, almost as if it were a cream base.

Thanks to the large choice of colors you’ll have at your fingertips, you can achieve both daytime and nighttime looks. That being said, the palette contains extremely rich colors like violet, deep blush tones and more, perfect for dramatic, smokey-eye looks and more. Needless to say, if you’re heading out to a night on the town, you’ll be turning heads wearing any of these brilliant colors.

Key Features
  • 100% vegan and cruelty-free
  • 16 earth tone hues in one palette
  • Portable lightweight case
Specifications
  • No. of Colors: 16
  • Dimensions: 5.6 x 3.7 x 0.4
  • Product Form: Solid powder
  • Waterproof: Yes
Pros
  • Designed for long wear
  • Features shimmery and matte colors
  • Highly pigmented
Cons
  • No mirror in compact
  • Color wears off too quickly

When it comes to displaying a beautiful array of eyeshadows, sometimes it’s all about the presentation. And with the L.A. Girl Beauty Eyeshadow, you’ll definitely appreciate its packaging. Designed to help you achieve your most beautiful looks at home and on-the-go, this book of 12 beautiful hues is a makeup must-have!

Unlike many other eyeshadow palettes like it, the LA Girl Beauty Eyeshadow comes complete with a conveniently wide mirror so you can get an ultra-close look at what you’re doing along with a double-sided brush to apply and blend to your heart’s content.

While this makeup brand boasts 4 beautiful palettes, their “NUDE” edition offers complete versatility. Whether you’re trying to get a date-night smoky eye or a subtle glow perfect for your best friend’s birthday brunch, you’ll never need any other shadows. This palette features a mix of matte and metallic hues with hints of greens, clay reds, and other beautiful earth tones.

Although the eyeshadows are made of powder, they go on incredibly smooth. While it’s advised to apply them over a primer or foundation base (which is a great thing to do when applying any eyeshadow), each color is deeply pigmented, giving stunning pops of color. Plus, since the different shades all compliment each other so well, you can mix and match them to create one-of-a-kind looks perfect for wearing day-to-day and to your most special occasions.

Key Features
  • 12 earth tone hues
  • Includes a dual-ended brush
  • Portable book casing
  • Available in 4 different types of palettes
  • Wide built-in mirror
Specifications
  • No. of Colors: 12
  • Dimensions: 8 x 0.5 6 x 2.6
  • Product Form: Powder
  • Waterproof: No
Pros
  • Everything you need for a smoky eye is in one palette
  • Super blendable
  • Easy to use on-the-go
Cons
  • Color doesn't "pop" as well on deeper complexions
  • Included brush doesn't blend that well
  • May have a slight odor upon opening

Tired of buying palettes containing “the best eyeshadow” only to realize you have to reapply it again and again throughout the day? Well, it’s time to kiss those days goodbye because Revlon has come to the rescue! Their 4-shade palette is designed to give you eye-popping color for up to 16 hours without you ever having to do any touch-ups.

While this little compact may look simple, it’s anything but basic. The palette contains four incredibly versatile shades that you can mix, match and blend as much as you’d like. Whether you’re donning a smoky eye or a simple shimmer, there’s no end to the number of looks you can achieve with this palette.

This compact contains the best eyeshadow simply because its powder base is extremely pigmented, giving you rich, decadent color with just a layer or two. And if this particular palette’s earthy tones aren’t your jam, there are a handful more to choose from, including cool blue tones to eye-popping lavender hues.

Plus, the compact comes with a teeny application brush so you can quickly dab on some color whenever you need. Thanks to the brush’s perfectly rounded tip, you can apply eyeshadow on your lids and blend it with a flick of the wrist. Whether you’re putting on just a hint of color or are going for a full-on contoured look, these brilliant shades will turn heads wherever you go!

Revlon further proves they manufacture the best eyeshadow by creating a long-lasting formula that is entomologist-tested, perfect for anyone with sensitive skin or eyes.

Key Features
  • 4-shade palette
  • Up to 16-hr color-stay technology
  • Ophthalmologist tested
  • Available in 4 palettes
  • Includes compact applicator
Specifications
  • No. of Colors: 4
  • Dimensions: 2.6 x 2.6 x 0.5 inches
  • Product Form: Powder
  • Waterproof: No
Pros
  • Gives rich, velvety color
  • Designed to resist smudging and creasing
  • Great for people with sensitive skin and eyes
Cons
  • Doesn't blend that well
  • Compact isn't super-durable
  • No mirror in compact

If you want to make a splash wherever you go, this Shimmer Liquid Shadow by Stila will not disappoint! Proving to be the best eyeshadow for bold, dramatic looks, the three included shades are fantastic for nights out on the town, special events and, of course, New Year’s Eve, the sparkliest holiday ever.

These liquid eyeshadows provide a fantastic shimmer without looking too campy. This high-quality deeply pigmented shadow has incredible staying power! After putting it on, you won’t have to worry about touching it up throughout your day or night. Additionally, the makeup doesn’t absorb into your skin, causing awkward lines or creasing on your lids.

And if you’re worried about the wet makeup getting into your eyes, don’t be. It dries rather quickly after application, making it practically impossible for it to accidentally drip into your eye. However, just before it dries, it stays moist just long enough for you to blend it, creating gorgeous, layered, shimmering looks that are sure to turn heads.

This particular pack of eyeshadows includes three shades: Starlight (which is light and champagne-colored), Kitten (a vibrant pink nude), and Vivid Smokey Quartz (a velvety brown hue). Whether you decide to blend the colors in a smokey eye or wear one at a time, these shimmering shades give your look that extra edge you’ve been looking for.

But what really makes this the best eyeshadow around is the fact that when using it, you never need to use any primer beforehand. That’s because this makeup goes on smoothly, without having a tacky, sticky texture — in other words, you’ll experience very minimal fall-out!

Key Features
  • Each color boasts a high impact sparkling effect
  • 3 earth tone shades
  • Wet brush applicator
Specifications
  • No. of Colors: 3
  • Dimensions: 2.8 x 0.7 x 3.8 inches
  • Product Form: Liquid
  • Waterproof: No
Pros
  • No primer needed
  • Incredibly rich color
  • Comprised of a pearl-like, translucent base
  • Great for making a statement
Cons
  • Two lighter colors are very similar after application
  • Harder to blend than powder eyeshadow

If you don’t want to turn heads wherever you go, this may not be the best eyeshadow for you. However, if you love making an impression on family, friends, and perfect strangers, this larger-than-life, brightly colored rainbow palette is just what the doctor ordered! Jam-packed with 18 incredible colors, you can achieve just about any look you could possibly dream of. In other words, this eyeshadow booklet is any makeup lover’s dream.

Each gorgeous color in the palette can easily be applied with brushes, sponges or even your fingers, and is creamy and buttery to the touch. This makes it incredibly convenient to apply and blend. The shades are all extremely pigmented and contain an array of finishes including shimmery, glittery and matte. With such vibrant colors at your fingertips, you can achieve one-of-a-kind looks perfect for weddings, vacations, parties, and other special occasions.

Thanks to the fact that you have so many hues to choose from, you won’t be stuck using the same exact colors every single day. You can also explore different looks, something you can’t necessarily do with more subdued, “safer” nude palettes.

Unlike many other eyeshadows on the market today, this palette is completely vegan, cruelty-free and paraben-free which is quite appealing for those trying to abide by a certain lifestyle. And because these colors are so versatile, you can also mix them with other makeup and materials, turning them into lipsticks, nail polish and makeup for the rest of your body.

Key Features
  • 18 bright shades
  • Highly pigmented
  • Longlasting and waterproof
  • Paraben-free, cruelty-free and vegan
  • Includes interior mirror
Specifications
  • No. of Colors: 18
  • Dimensions: 7.3 x 4.1 x 0.6 inches
  • Product Form: Powder
  • Waterproof: Yes
Pros
  • Unique colors are ideal for dramatic looks
  • Super creamy upon application
  • Massive amount of colors all in one easy-to-carry booklet
Cons
  • Could stand to be more pigmented
  • Has a paint-like odor

Look, you’re always on the go, and spending tons of time in the bathroom at home every morning putting on your makeup just isn’t an option. That’s why this super-portable, BYS Eyeshadow Palette is the best eyeshadow option for you. Small enough to fit in your pocket or smallest purse, this palette is great for touch-ups in the car, at the office, or in the bathroom while on a very special date!

Each compact contains a beautiful six shades, all perfectly complementing each other. No matter which of the four compacts you choose (each with different types of matching hues), the colors are designed to each play a part in the perfectly made-up eye. That’s right, when using this palette, you won’t need to bring in any other outside shadows! You’ll have access to deep shades to outline your eyes, shimmery shades to apply to the corners and edges of your lids, and other hues that will give your eyes incredible depth.

In the compact, you’ll find a perfectly compact dual-ended brush, great for applying any eye makeup style, whether it be a dramatic look or a more understated one. The compact also boasts an attached mirror in its interior so you can literally touch up your eyes anywhere.

None of the manufacturer’s palettes are ever tested on animals and boast incredible staying power and blendability. And while the compact may seem little, it’s jam-packed with attention-grabbing power!

Key Features
  • Compact case designed to take on-the-go
  • Includes interior mirror and double-ended applicator brush
  • 6 matte shades
  • Available in four palettes
Specifications
  • No. of Colors: 6
  • Dimensions: 0.6 x 4.9 x 4.4 inches
  • Product Form: Powder
  • Waterproof: No
Pros
  • Complimenting shades are ideal for blending and contouring
  • Shades are true to color and highly pigmented
  • Makeup not tested on animals
Cons
  • Compact brush is hard to hold
  • May have to retouch throughout the day

You may be all grown up, but that doesn’t mean you’re too old to want to look like a mermaid! All joking aside, this Original Mermaid Glitter Eyeshadow Palette boasts a little bit of glitter, gorgeous color and a little bit of magic, making it the best eyeshadow palette for adventurous makeup wearers. Complete with 32 shades of varying finishes and hues, the number of looks you can achieve with the palette are practically infinite.

What truly sets this palette apart from others like it is its incredible amount of vibrant colors. First off, it contains 21 holographic glitter shades, perfect for taking regular bold looks to a whole new level! The palette also features 6 shimmery shades that are pressed, highly pigmented and fantastic for blending. Finally, the booklet contains 5 matte stains that are also heavily pigmented and ideal for creating smoky eyes and other sultry looks.

Thanks to the fact that you’ll have so many incredible colors at your disposal, you’ll have the opportunity to experiment with different looks like never before. Whether you’re a makeup novice or a full-on professional, these colors make it possible to achieve just about any look you desire. Plus, the colors are so versatile, they can be used as eyeliner, nail polish and body paint, given that you apply the right type of moisture to them.

Along with boasting a wide array of dazzling hues, these eyeshadows are also ideal for those carrying out a vegan lifestyle. The makeup is completely vegan and cruelty-free and comes from a company that prides itself on being a friend to people and the environment.

Key Features
  • Easy to blend shades
  • 32 highly pigmented hues
  • Mix of matte, glitter and metallic finishes
  • Can be used for eyes, nails and body
  • Booklet contains interior mirror
  • Vegan and cruelty-free formula
Specifications
  • No. of Colors: 32
  • Dimensions: 20.2 x 15.6 x 3 inches
  • Product Form: Powder
  • Waterproof: Yes
Pros
  • Incredibly versatile
  • Has a wide mix of mattes, glitters and pearl finishes
  • Perfect for anyone living a clean, vegan lifestyle
  • Good for those with sensitive skin
Cons
  • Colors might be too bright and sparkly for some

Picking out the best eyeshadow isn't about settling for one single product. There are tons of options out there and lucky for you, settling for just one is not a good thing! Applying eyeshadow is all about blending multiple colors and textures together to create one killer look. That being said, there are definitely some eyeshadows that may be better or worse for you, it all just depends on what you need it for.

To help you decide on the best eyeshadow products for you, here's a little cheat sheet to match you with exactly what you need!

Best eyeshadow for work-friendly looks

If you love wearing makeup but are forced to tone it down for work, a religious function or whatever else, it's always good to stick with subtle colors that compliment your eye color. If you have blue eyes, sticking with shadows with a brown hue are always great. Go with shades that have a minimal sheen or that are completely matte.

If you have green or hazel eyes, you can go with violet and purple hues — just don't get too crazy. Stick with rich purple shades like a matte burgundy. If you're a brown-eyed beauty, you can really wear any color as long as it's applied conservatively. If you really want some contrast, blue or grey always goes nicely with brown eyes. And if you are sporting green eyes, warm tones like red-brown and peach are always beautiful and subtle.

Best eyeshadow for bold looks

Want to make a splash on a girls' night out or make an impression on a first date? A gorgeous bold eye is definitely a must! Variations on the classic smoky eye are very in right now, and it allows you to not only experiment with color but with texture as well, and you can even use your eyeshadow as an eyeliner.

If you're going for a smoky eye, the best eyeshadows to use are ones that go well together, which you can often find in a booklet or palette. Typically, you'll put darker shades on the lid and around it and blend it with highlighting shades in the inner corners and creases of your eyes. If you really want to make heads turn, make sure one of the eyeshadows is glittery or has metallic elements to make your look more dynamic.

But remember, don't pick the same texture for every shade. A mix of sheen with matte shades can make your eyes pop without making look like a Sephora exploded onto your face.

Best eyeshadow for sensitive eyes

If you're worried about getting irritated eyes, be sure to read the ingredients on your eyeshadows. The best eyeshadows will have minimal harsh ingredients and will often say things like "paraben-free" to let you know it contains less dangerous chemicals.

And if you choose to live a vegan lifestyle, many eyeshadows on the market boast cruelty-free and vegan formulas.

 

Resources — New You, Makeup Geek

Share this Buyers Guide