www.reviewthis.com

The 10 Best Liquid Eyeliners of 2019

Liquid Eyeliner: The Best of 2019

It’s the one final touch that makes our beauty routine come together like a dream — and the one single thing which can make our eyes appear bigger, bolder, and especially enchanting with just a few skillfully applied strokes.

No wonder the world has been enchanted with eyeliner for centuries, from ancient monarchs to queens of the silver screen and our very favorite celebs.

And adding the best liquid eyeliner to your beauty supply arsenal will not only mean you get to cast the same magic spell with your gaze but will also ensure you’re able to make it come especially alive in a way nothing else can.

And even though eyeliners do come in different varieties — pencils and gels, included — we've chosen the one category that is guaranteed to provide you with that intense, bold color, all with a minimum of fuss. And it's not just any kind: It's the very best liquid eyeliners.

This liquid eyeliner is brought to you courtesy of a manufacturer which not only guarantees that it’s the perfect product for every occasion but will also leave you with fuller longer lashes meaning you’re actually getting two products for the price of one. And because intriguing offers always warrant a closer look, we decided to check out the Lavish Liner, to see if it was truly as amazing as promised.

We must admit that we were rather pleasantly surprised as we got to tick one box after another until we found that every promise had been kept. It was not only easy to apply, but perfect for every style making it the ideal choice for creating our favorite effects for every occasion.

It was waterproof too, making it especially immune to perspiration and ideal for putting our surfing skills to the test.

What’s more, it simply remained wonderfully smudge and smear proof throughout the day right until washed off with soap and water.

But what about its claim to be able to provide longer lashes? Well there’s the fact that the manufacturer actually produces its very own eyelash growth serum and so does know a thing or two about helping their clients grow longer, lusher lashes. And they’ve actually infused the Lavish Liner with a part of their special formula which contains biotin and castor oil: ingredients which are renowned for being extremely hair-follicle friendly and promoting growth and suppleness.

Were we pleased with what we found? Absolutely. If you’d love an eyeliner that will not only make your eyes look beautiful but also take care of your eyelashes too, then the Lavish Liner might be just what you’re looking for.

Key Features
  • Special 2-in-1 formula infused with eyelash growth serum
  • Unique water, smudge and perspiration resistant formula
  • Hypoallergenic and cruelty free formula
Specifications
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Wear Time: All day
  • Product Form: liquid
  • Weight: 0.8 ounces
  • Brand: Hairgenics Pronexa
Pros
  • Hypoallergenic and suitable for sensitive skin
  • Waterproof and smudge proof formula
  • Cruelty free formula
Cons
  • Dries quickly

Products which are hypoallergenic seem few and far between and that’s why we often tend to take notice whenever one makes an appearance. Particularly when it’s been manufactured by a brand which seems to know a thing or two about beauty, just like Neutrogena.

One of the main complaints about liquid eyeliner is the fact that it is considered a tad difficult to apply, however, the Neutrogena Precision Liquid Eyeliner with Honey & Coconut eyeliner comes with a special applicator which makes getting those perfect lines rather easy.

And that means bidding farewell to several failed attempts at getting the perfect cat eye and watching it all come together beautifully.

But a special applicator won’t be much use if your eyeliner isn’t capable of providing that luxuriant depth of color, and thankfully, that is another all-important box which can be ticked off with this product: this is one eyeliner which seems to have been manufactured with an extra helping of pigment making it perfect for creating precise lines that are simply delightful.

It’s also waterproof too making it a superb choice for those warm summer perspiration-prone days. What's more, it's long lasting, meaning you won’t have to worry about having to look for a comfy spot to reapply it while you’re out and about enjoying your day.

And there’s the icing on the cake: the fact that it’s hypoallergenic which, in addition to all the amazing qualities listed above, simply sets it apart from the rest and makes it worthy of consideration if you happen to be in search of an eyeliner which will be gentle on your eyes while making them look especially alluring.

Key Features
  • Special applicator for creating perfect lines
  • Hypoallergenic formula which is ideal for sensitive eyes
  • Unique waterproof formula containing high levels of pigment
Specifications
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Wear Time: All day
  • Product Form: Liquid
  • Weight: 0.48 ounces
Pros
  • Capable of resisting perspiration
  • Ideal for creating precise lines
  • An impressive depth of color
Cons
  • Insufficient quantity

Ultra-thin, intense black lines are unmatched in their ability to make your eyes appear especially enchanting and highlight the beauty of your eye makeup as well.

But when it comes to executing them not just any eyeliner will do. Especially since it takes a product capable of delivering on that intense black capable of enlivening everything around it, with the right kind of applicator - a super thin brush.

And that's where the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vinyl Liquid Liner comes in. Brought to you by a renowned manufacturer with products which have garnered rave reviews, this is one offering which simply does what you expect liquid eyeliner to: provide those smooth magical strokes in a vivid black which will make the colors of your makeup stand out.

In an industry inundated by eyeliners of all kinds, this eyeliner’s truly dark pigmented black is so deep that it will leave you feeling impressed.

There’s also that fine brush applicator which is the ideal choice for providing those super fine lines which are the hallmark of elegant makeup as well as cat and winged eyes which always add a really special touch of their own. And it’s also ideal for creating thicker lines if you intend to switch things up for a more dramatic effect.

All these qualities make the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vinyl Liquid Liner the ideal choice if you happen to be searching for a no-frills eyeliner which not only contains a high level of pigment but is also long-lasting.

Key Features
  • Long lasting formula
  • Vivid black color
  • Fine brush for detailed application
Specifications
  • Waterproof: No
  • Wear Time: All day
  • Product Form: Liquid
  • Weight: 0.64 ounces
Pros
  • Super thin brush for versatile application
  • High pigment content
  • Impressively long lasting
Cons
  • Brush quality could be improved

If you're a fan of makeup, you will agree that the feeling of satisfaction that comes with a perfectly executed cat eye is pretty hard to beat. Especially when it gets done in record time.

And that's what makes the Winged Eyeliner Stamp by Lovoir Black seem almost too good to be true.

After all, it isn't that often that you come across a product which promises to help you get it right.

But that's exactly what this eyeliner does. And it's all thanks to its tips which end in a stamp and an applicator. Which means you get to apply your cat eye and connect it to your tip, all with a minimum of fuss.

And there are also two eyeliners — one for your left eye and the other for your right, so that you get to achieve a symmetry which is perfect. Talk about amazing!

But of course there's that all important sample test which must be carried out before you apply it which involves dabbing a bit of it on the inside of your wrist to ensure your skin isn't allergic to it. Any discomfort means you'll need to discontinue using it at once to avoid an allergic reaction on your eyelids.

But if it all proceeds smoothly, you'll be able to enjoy a product which has not only been made from high quality products and is easy to use, but is long lasting and especially waterproof.

And there's also the fact that it comes with a high level of pigment making for a vivid, bold black which will make your gaze especially vibrant.

If you'd love to enjoy perfectly executed makeup and the immense satisfaction that comes with it, treating yourself to the Winged Eyeliner Stamp by Lovoir Black might turn out to be an amazing idea.

Key Features
  • Dual tipped eyeliner with applicator and stamp
  • Unique formula containing high levels of pigment
  • Special long lasting and waterproof formula
Specifications
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Wear Time: All day
  • Product Form: Liquid
  • Weight: 0.8 ounces
Pros
  • A set of 2 eyeliners with stamps for both eyes
  • Impressively waterproof and long lasting
  • Innovative design consisting of stamp and applicator
Cons
  • May provoke an allergic reaction in certain skin types

There aren’t too many manufacturers that take the effort to get their liquid eyeliner tested by an ophthalmologist - an extra bit of attention to detail which we found rather impressive and which piqued our curiosity, prompting us to take a closer peek at the Revlon ColorStay Skinny Liquid Eyeliner.

There was also the fact that its manufacturer also happens to be one of the most successful brands in the beauty industry.

And quite happily, we were rather pleased to find that this was one liquid eyeliner which did live up to our expectations.

There was its ultra precise 0.1mm tip which made it extra easy to get those extra fine thin lines right in one stroke - and therefore an excellent choice for a cat or winged-eye effect - as well as the fact that you could actually create your prefered thickness, too.

There was also the fact that it had been rigorously tested making it an ideal choice for sensitive eyes and wearers of contact lenses.

What’s more, the Revlon ColorStay Skinny Liquid Eyeliner also proved especially resistant to smudging and smearing and was also remarkably long lasting.

All these impressive qualities mean that this is one eyeliner which is pretty hard to say no to if you’d love to highlight the beauty of your eyes on a regular basis with a high quality product.

Key Features
  • Special long lasting, smudge proof formula
  • Precise 0.1mm tip for creating extra fine lines in one stroke
  • Unique formula which is ideal for individuals with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
Specifications
  • Waterproof: No
  • Wear Time: All day
  • Product Form: Liquid
  • Weight: 0.48 ounces
Pros
  • Unique formula which is ideal for individuals with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • Precise 0.1mm tip for creating extra fine lines in one stroke
  • Special long lasting, smudge proof formula
Cons
  • May smudge

Any product which has earned a rather prestigious award from makeup fans must come with a thing or two which has enabled it to outstrip the competition — after all, being crowned winner of the Teen Vogue Beauty Award is no mean feat in an industry which is one of the most competitive on the globe.

So what is it about the Eyeko Skinny Liquid Liner which has earned it an army of faithful fans?

First of all, there's its special formula which comes in an impressively deep black and which has also been infused with a conditioning algae extract and is perfect for daily use.

There’s also its applicator tip which is finely tapered and has been designed with just the right balance of firmness and flexibility making it the ideal choice for the perfect cat eyes and fine, intense dark lines which always provide the perfect finishing touch needed to highlight your eye makeup in all its glory. And that means it does contain the main qualities every great eyeliner is meant to come with.

No wonder it’s loved by fans all over the globe. And you too can get to add this amazing wand to your makeup collection and experience its magic each morning creating a gaze which is nothing short of enchanting.

Key Features
  • Unique algae infused conditioning formula
  • Finely tapered brush for applying fine lines and cat eyes
  • Impressively long lasting formula
Specifications
  • Waterproof: No
  • Wear Time: All day
  • Product Form: Liquid
  • Weight: 0.48 ounces
Pros
  • Finely tapered applicator tip with the perfect balance of firmness and flexibility
  • Long lasting formula
  • Impressively intense black color
Cons
  • Not waterproof

Have you ever dreamed of a liquid eyeliner which is easy to use, would line your lids smoothly without any clumps and follow the curve of your eyelid in one continuous sweep of bold color?

Then the LORAC Front of the Line PRO Liquid Eyeliner might just be what you need to make your daily makeup routine complete.

This product which is free from parabens, sulfates, phthalates as well as synthetic dyes and fragrances, will provide a continuous unbroken thin line or a thicker finish over your eyelids thanks to its applicator which has been specially designed to ensure you’re able to apply it as smoothly as possible.

It’s also long lasting and especially smudge and waterproof meaning that you’ll be able to head out each morning without worrying about your eyeliner suddenly vanishing or worse still becoming runny on a hot summer afternoon or during a sudden and unexpected spring downpour. What’s more, its special formula means that it will even be able to withstand the oil which tends to accumulate on your skin during the day.

All these features make the LORAC Front of the Line PRO Liquid Eyeliner not only safe to use, but also a dependable beauty product which will not only highlight your makeup skills and the color of your eyes, but will withstand those random agents - water, sebum and perspiration - which can often ruin our very best efforts.

And that might just make it the eyeliner dreams are made of.

Key Features
  • Long lasting, water and smudge proof formula
  • A special formula free from parabens, sulfates and phthalates
  • A special applicator for precise lines
Specifications
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Wear Time: All day
  • Product Form: Liquid
  • Weight: 0.32 ounces
Pros
  • Perfect for fine or heavier lines
  • Long lasting formula
  • Waterproof and smudge proof
Cons
  • Consistency may not be as smooth as desired

“The Eyeliner you've never heard of that everyone's talking about”, that’s MIA ADORA’s opening introduction for the product which they’ve christened their best eyeliner. But now you’ve heard about it, what are the chances you might consider it yours?

First of all, it comes with the high pigment content which provides the intense deep color which separates liquid eyeliners from their counterparts in other categories - and which in this case, is considered by its manufacturer to be absolutely unique and in a class of its own.

And when applied, it dries promptly ensuring you can proceed with the rest of your routine. It’s also long lasting and will last for 12 hours after it’s been applied and is waterproof making it an ideal choice for all seasons.

There’s also its pen like tip which enhances the ease with which you get to apply lines of any thickness with a minimum of fuss.

What’s more, its manufacturer has also gone the extra mile to ensure that the ingredients used in their eyeliner which comes with a list of rather impressive qualities, are cruelty free and haven’t been tested on any animals.

With all these qualities, it's pretty clear that this is one liquid eyeliner which comes with everything you could possibly desire in a product in this category - even though we think it would have been amazing if it were hypoallergenic, too.

If you've been searching for a liquid eyeliner which ticks almost every box, the MIA ADORA Waterproof Eyeliner Pen might be worth checking out.

Key Features
  • Fast drying, long lasting formula
  • A cruelty-free product
  • Unique waterproof formula with impressive high pigment content
Specifications
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Wear Time: 12 hours
  • Product Form: liquid
  • Weight: 0.32 ounces
Pros
  • Capable of lasting 12 hours
  • A cruelty free product
  • Fast drying, intense formula
Cons
  • May feel somewhat rough during application
  • May not last as long as desired

We all love eyeliners which let us step out looking as though our makeup has been done by a pro. Especially when they’re extremely responsive, enable great precision and seem as though they come with an extra helping of pigment.

And the NYX Epic Ink Liner seems to tick all those boxes, and a lot more too.

It’s also long lasting and smudge proof which is a great thing since it wouldn’t be much use to have an eyeliner which delivered when it came to boldness of color and application only to mysteriously vanish soon after or worse still get smudged ruining your carefully applied handiwork right before that all-important interview.

Thankfully, this is one product with which you’ll never have to worry about any dreaded smudging.

And in the event of your having to redo your eyes, there’ll be no need to worry about any telltale double layers which may occur with certain eyeliner brands.

And in addition to providing a product which ticks so many boxes wonderfully, the manufacturer has ensured that the NYX Epic Ink Liner is also a product which is cruelty free and hasn’t been tested on any animals.

If you’d like an eyeliner which is a firm favorite among makeup professionals and will make you look glamorous, rain or shine, and which is also cruelty free, there’s no doubt that the NYX Epic Ink Liner may form a very welcome addition to your makeup collection.

Key Features
  • Unique smudge proof, long lasting formula
  • A waterproof formula capable of lasting through rain or shine
  • A cruelty-free product
Specifications
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Wear Time: All day
  • Product Form: Liquid
  • Weight: 0.48 ounces
Pros
  • Special extra responsive tip for greater precision
  • A long lasting, waterproof formula
  • A cruelty free product
Cons
  • May be unsuitable for extremely oily skin

It isn’t that often that we get to come across a product which seems as though it’s been put together by a fairy godmother and conjured into existence.

And that’s what the Docolor Waterproof Eyeliner seems like at a first glance. There’s its intense pigment which is an all-important factor for highlighting the colors of your eyes and makeup, as well as the fact that it’s actually capable of defying rather oily eyelids and keeping its promise to last for 12 hours making it a product which succeeds wonderfully where several others have achieved less than stellar results – all at an awesome price, too.

In addition to being incredibly intense and impressively long lasting, it’s also waterproof, just like the very best eyeliners are meant to be. What’s more, it’s also great for sensitive skin which reduces the likelihood of makeup fans missing out on just how great it is.

In addition to the impressive level of detail paid by the manufacturer to providing a superb eyeliner formula, there’s also its felt tip pen which is capable of maintaining the continuous flow which is essential for providing perfectly executed lines.

Long lasting, waterproof, a deep vivid hue, and suitable for sensitive skin - not to mention a felt tip pen which will ensure you get to draw those lines perfectly.

We think that’s what the best liquid eyeliners are made of and if you do too, then making the Docolor Waterproof Eyeliner a part of your daily makeup routine might be an excellent idea.

Key Features
  • Intense black formula
  • Long lasting, waterproof formula
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes
Specifications
  • Waterproof: Yes
  • Wear Time: 12 hours
  • Product Form: liquid
  • Weight: 0.8 ounces
Pros
  • Ideal for sensitive skin
  • Waterproof, vivid black formula
  • Capable of lasting for 12 hours
Cons
  • May irritate very sensitive skin

Why liquid eyeliner is the best eyeliner

So what is it about liquid eyeliners that makes them deserving of a special mention and why do they deserve a coveted spot in your makeup collection?For starters, there are those awesome qualities which they possess which neither gel nor pencils can quite live up to:

how liquid eyeliner provides Detailed definition

When it comes to creating that alluring cat-eye effect, not to mention that winged-eye trick, you need an eyeliner which can provide you with stunning precision capable of producing perfection no other variety of eyeliner will be able to emulate. Opting for liquid eyeliner will enable you to imbue your gaze with a bold enchanting appeal and a hint of extra glamour.

Bolder colors with liquid eyeliner

There are times when bolder is better, especially when an extra touch of color and sparkle are required: that music festival you’ve bought tickets for, well in advance, a night out clubbing from dusk to dawn or an evening spent hanging out with your friends at that trendy new bar.

And you can be certain that liquid eyeliner can be relied upon to deliver that intense touch of color which will not only make your gaze especially vivid but will also enable you to add to the electric atmosphere of those fun spots too.

Resistance to sun, sea, and surf

When it comes to selecting eyeliners, we all deserve a product which will not only form the perfect complement to a flawless backdrop, but will also endure the rigors of sunshine, perspiration, and that occasional splash amidst the waves. After all, there’s no reason why we should endure a trade-off between looking glamorous and enjoying our favorite things.

And that’s where the best liquid eyeliners come in. They’re not only capable of resisting the potent makeup busting effects of sunshine, perspiration, and even saltwater, but will also maintain their flawless appeal through it all, making them the ideal option for making the most of your summer.

Eyeliners that come with the boldest color, provide excellent definition and are ideal for a splash in the sea. How could anyone possibly resist that? Especially since there are many more perks to using liquid eyeliners.

And to discover them, all you need to do is go through the list below which consists of our very favorite selections. In it, we discuss what sets them apart from the rest, what we like about them and the qualities we wish they had. And by the time you get to the end of it all, you’ll know just what to look for when it comes to selecting the best liquid eyeliners for your makeup collection.

Resources— Dermstore, Byrdie, Refinery29, Grazia

Share this Buyers Guide