www.reviewthis.com

The 10 Best Mattress Toppers of 2019

Mattress Toppers: The Best of 2019

The Linenspa Gel Swirl Memory Foam Mattress Topper features a combination of high-quality memory foam, for contouring and support, and swirls of gel, for cooling and comfort.

A unique feature about the Linenspa Gel Swirl Memory Foam Mattress Topper is that not only is it gel-infused, but it’s also open-cell memory foam, which further enhances breathability and increased air flow to allow for ultimate temperature control.

Since this mattress topper is not 100% memory foam, it is better suited for those without severe back pain or injuries, because although it does provide contoured support and even weight distribution, it may not provide sufficient support for those with certain medical conditions.

The Linenspa Gel Swirl Memory Foam Mattress Topper is perfect for those who sleep hot at night, as the product’s double approach to temperature control from the gel and open cells provides unmatched cool air flow to minimize nighttime overheating.

However, the Linenspa does more than just keep you cool at night. Utilizing a high-quality memory foam, the Linenspa also effectively contours the body to provide proper spinal alignment and evenly balances your weight across the mattress.

As with other memory foam products, the primary drawback to the Linenspa is its propensity to tear or crack after extended use. Luckily, the manufacturer does offer a 3-year guarantee on its product, and the company is known to provides excellent service in honoring this warranty.

Another complaint about this topper was its strong, chemical odor upon initial receipt of the product. For this reason, the company recommends airing it out for 48 hours in order for the smell to completely dissipate.

Despite its drawbacks, we found the Linenspa Gel Swirled Memory Foam Mattress Topper to be a smart choice for those whose primary concern is cool nighttime comfort, while still maintaining a high level of contouring and support.

Key Features
  • A combination of CertiPUR-US certified memory foam and gel
  • Open-cell memory foam for breathability
  • Choose your thickness level: 2, 3, or 4 inches
Specifications
  • Dimensions: 14.6 x 14.6 x 23.7 inches queen
  • Weight: 4.41 pounds
  • Material: CertiPUR US-Certified Memory Foam and Gel
  • Brand: Linenspa
  • Warranty: 3 years
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Ca King
Pros
  • High quality memory foam
  • Open-cell design aids in breathability
  • Gel provides cooling
Cons
  • Not pure memory foam
  • Strong initial chemical odor

So, you would really LOVE to own a Tempur-Pedic mattress, but you don’t have a spare $2,000 lying around? Yeah, us either. Now you can do the next best thing and transform your existing mattress into a Tempur-Pedic with the Tempur-ProForm Supreme 3-Inch Mattress Topper.

Tempur-Pedic is probably synonymous in your mind with memory foam mattresses— after all, they ARE the originators. Originally developed for NASA astronauts to absorb the G-Force while blasting into space, Tempur-Pedic brought this advanced motion absorbing technology to the masses and allowed all of us non-space travelers a chance to orbit Planet Dreamland.

And while budget constraints may stop you from purchasing a Tempur-Pedic mattress, the mattress topper is a whole lot more affordable. This is definitely the highest price point of all the mattress toppers we reviewed, but honestly it seems to be worth it.

A quarter century of testing and development went into creating Tempur-Pedic’s iconic product, and you can reap those same benefits from using their topper, which features material identical to their mattress. Tempur-Pedic memory foam is designed to provide the ultimate in comfort and support while eliminating painful pressure points for an individualized sleep experience.

The Tempur-Pedic mattress topper is a solid 3 inches thick, and the company touts the durability of their product as superior to that of any competitor. The Tempur-Pedic mattress topper also features a removable, machine washable cover that is breathable and dust mite resistant.

The biggest drawback to the Tempur-Pedic mattress topper is definitely its price, which is several hundred dollars higher than its competitors. However, the Tempur-Pedic includes a 10 year warranty, which, although also offered by other companies, is more of an assurance coming from this manufacturer due to their length of time in business. Other complaints about the Tempur-Pedic were standard concerns with the product’s odor and the Temper material becoming damaged. Again, Tempur-Pedics customer service seems to provide great support and effectively resolves any issues that may arise.

If you can afford it and are set on a memory foam mattress topper, we’d definitely recommend getting a Tempur-Pedic for all of the many benefits it offers.

Key Features
  • 3-inch thick Tempur material
  • Features a washable, removable allergen resistant cover
  • Provides the ultimate contouring and support, while relieving pressure points
Specifications
  • Dimensions: 80" x 60" x 3" queen
  • Weight: 35.1 pounds
  • Material: Tempur material
  • Brand: Tempur-Pedic
  • Warranty: 10 years
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Ca King
Pros
  • 3 inches ultra thick memory foam
  • Same material as used in Tempur-Pedic's mattresses at a fraction of the cost
  • Made in the US
  • Provides maximum contouring and support
Cons
  • Initially has a strong, chemically odor

If price is a major concern when shopping for a mattress topper, and you’d also like the ease of machine washing your bedding, you may want to consider the Oaskys Pillow Top Cooling Mattress Topper.

The Oaskys consists of a snow down alternative filling enclosed in a 300 thread count combed cotton cover. The Oaskys utilizes an elastic band to securely fasten itself to your bed, eliminating the need to constantly straighten and reposition the mattress topper.

Combed cotton is known for its cooling nature, and the Oaskys combines this with 49 ouncs of shredded memory foam filling to provide a mattress topper that is refreshing, breathable, and soft.

It is important to note, however, that this mattress topper provides very little in the way of support and doesn’t reduce transfer of motion. If you suffer from back pain or find you are disturbed by your partner’s stirring, the Oaskys won’t provide you with the right sleep environment. Instead, it is designed for those wanting to add a cloud-like feeling to an overly firm mattress.

What in lacks in the way of serious support, the Oaskys makes up for in its ease of use. You simply slip the Oaskys over your mattress with the elastic band and it attaches and wraps around in the same manner as a fitted sheet. Whenever cleaning is needed, simply remove it and throw it in the washer as you would a comforter. Drying should be done on a low temperature setting to avoid pilling, lint, or shrinkage.

The Oaskys is hypoallergenic and its snow down alternative filling is designed to mimic the feel of pure down, minus the allergies. The cover is made from pure cotton, which eliminates the possibility of rash or irritation and makes the Oaskys a great choice for allergy sufferers and the budget conscious alike.

Key Features
  • Topper features down alternative filling in a cotton case
  • 100 percent combed cotton for superior breathability and cool nights sleep
  • Features an elastic band to securely attach to bed, and a diamond-quilted design for even fill distribution
Specifications
  • Dimensions: 59.1" x 78.7" x 47.2 inches
  • Weight: 5.51 pounds
  • Material: Shredded memory foam/cotton
  • Brand: Oaskys
  • Warranty: Satisfaction Guarantee
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Full XL, Queen, Olympic Queen, King, Ca King
Pros
  • Natural combed cotton
  • Soft and cool
  • Machine washable for easy care
Cons
  • Not highly supportive
  • Doesn’t contour or stop transfer of motion

If you find yourself torn between the softness of memory foam and the cooling nature of gel, the Linenspa Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper may be your perfect fit. Pure memory foam is known to retain heat, which can be uncomfortable if you’re prone to nighttime sweating. The Linenspa’s gel beads work to regulate and distribute heat evenly across the topper, so the temperature in your bed remains consistent.

Another benefit of the Linenspa Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper is that it’s made from CertiPUR-US Certified foam. While other competing mattress toppers may feature low-quality foam or foam byproducts, a CertiPUR-US Certified product has met the required standards for quality in the United States.

The only downside to the Linenspa Mattress Topper: like other memory foam products, some reviewers complained of a chemically, gassy odor upon opening the box. However, the odor does seem to fade and become less noticeable with time, due to the natural “airing out” process.

Also, memory foam is prone to ripping and tearing quite easily, so you’ll always want to handle with care. Due its delicate nature, it is not recommended to fold up the topper when not in use. Instead this needs to be used as a permanent addition to your mattress, rather than as an occasional fold and go extra guest bed option.

Despite the odor and propensity to tear, the Linenspa Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper is a smart all-around choice and features many benefits that will work for the vast majority of bed and sleep type situations.

Key Features
  • Made from ultra-plush memory foam
  • Infused with temperature regulating gel beads
  • Memory foam designed to evenly distribute weight
Specifications
  • Dimensions: 79 x 59 x 2 inches (Queen)
  • Weight: 10.95 pounds
  • Material: CertiPUR US-Certified Memory Foam
  • Brand: Linenspa
  • Warranty: 3 year
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Full XL, Queen, King, Ca King
Pros
  • Cooling gel beads
  • Can choose thickness level: 2 or 3 inches
  • Quality memory foam
Cons
  • Chemical odor
  • Tears easily

If the thought of gel infusions and bright pigments swirling through your mattress topper makes you nervous, your best buy may be the Recci 3-inch Memory Foam Mattress Topper. The Recci mattress topper takes the "simpler is better" approach. Therefore, you won’t find any egg crate texture or charcoal infusion in this bedding, but rather a pure, eco-friendly memory foam topper.

And while pure memory foam is known to get very warm during the night, the Recci relies on its bamboo cover to keep you cool and comfortable. Utilizing a proprietary weave method, the cover encourages air flow throughout the mattress topper, and regulates temperature to ensure you don’t experience heat-related discomfort. Some people, however, might still find this mattress cover makes them too hot. The only downside to the cover acting as the source of cooling-power is, eventually it will need to be removed for laundering, and you’ll have to go without any temperature control during this time.

Pure memory foam provides the ultimate in support and comfort, and contours to the curves and motions of your body. This means you won’t experience any pressure points from lying on pure memory foam, and since your body is properly supported throughout the night it allows you to wake without the typical morning stiffness.

The memory foam in the Recci is both CertiPUR-US and OEKO-TX certified for quality, durability and purity of contents. This topper is also flame-retardant and free from harmful substances such as formaldehyde, lead, and mercury, and has low VOC emissions.

While it is priced on the higher side, the Recci boasts a thickness of 3 inches, which accounts for this added cost. Overall, the Recci is a great choice for those who want pure memory foam without unnecessary extra features and potentially harmful substances.

Key Features
  • Simple, eco-friendly pure memory foam
  • Free from pigments, gel or additives
  • Mattress topper utilizes bamboo viscose cover for cool feeling
Specifications
  • Dimensions: 60 x 80 x 3 inches
  • Weight: 19.1 pounds
  • Material: CertiPUR-US and OEKO-TX certified memory foam
  • Brand: Recci
  • Warranty: 30 day returns/10 year warranty
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Full, Queen, King, Ca King
Pros
  • CertiPUR and OEKO-TX certified
  • 3-inch thickness
  • Cooling bamboo cover
Cons
  • Memory foam gets hot during night

If you’ve had poor luck with memory foam or are just seeking a different type of material, the Pure Green 100 percent Natural Latex Mattress Topper offers a high-quality alternative. Made from pure 100 percent natural latex, without any type of synthetic fillers or additives, the Pure Green is produced using a molding process that provides a superior topper over competing continuous-pour latex products.

The Pure Green mattress topper is 2 inches thick (and also comes in 1- and 3-inch versions) and is soft yet supportive. If you don’t like the feeling of sinking into the mattress that you can sometimes experience with a memory foam, you’ll love the resilience of latex. Pure Green utilizes Dunlop latex, which provides a springy feel to the topper, however it won’t have the bounce of Talalay processed latex. Instead, this product is intended to provide a resilient sleep experience that will hold its shape and loft, even after nightly use.

Competing toppers are often produced using mostly synthetic latex and contain just a small amount of natural latex mixed in, so that the mattress topper can be marketed as a “natural” product. The Pure Green contains no synthetic latex, gel, or any other type of fillers that serve to water down the topper and take up space within the foam. Basically, what you see on the outside of the Pure Green mattress topper is what you get throughout the product.

While not produced in the US, Pure Green mattress toppers are manufactured in Sri Lanka due to the country’s vast natural resources. In fact, the same natural latex material which is harvested from the island’s rubberwood trees is used to produce the Pure Green mattress topper.

The only drawback to the Pure Green is that, like most latex, it does tend to be very heavy and bulky, and some may have difficulty moving the topper onto their bed or tucking it under a fitted sheet. However, if you are not concerned with the heaviness of your topper but instead prefer softness and durability, the Pure Green 100% Natural Latex Mattress Topper may be your perfect choice.

Key Features
  • 100% natural latex, no synthetics
  • Softens a “too-firm” mattress
  • Natural latex is far more durable then polyurethane or memory foam
Specifications
  • Dimensions: 60 x 80 x 2 inches Queen
  • Weight: 24.4 pounds
  • Material: Latex
  • Brand: Pure Green
  • Warranty: Standard Amazon return policy
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Ca King
Pros
  • 100% natural product
  • Durable and resilient
  • Maintains its contouring support
Cons
  • Heavy and bulky
  • Won’t work for those with latex allergies

If you’re looking for a memory foam topper that has its own unique set of benefits, you may be interested in the Lucid Bamboo Charcoal Memory Foam Mattress Topper.

The Lucid utilizes bamboo that has been freshly burned at a high temperature and ground into a fine powder. Added to their memory foam construction, the bamboo charcoal assists with temperature and odor control and provides a cooler, cleaner sleep experience.

The Lucid features a plush memory foam that contours and conforms to your body while eliminating pressure points, so that you wake feeling refreshed and pain free. The Lucid also comes with tiny holes throughout the topper, which allows for proper airflow and ventilation so that you stay cool as you sleep.

Another benefit to the Lucid mattress topper is that you’re able to choose your thickness level from 2, 3, or 4 inches. The company touts the higher thickness toppers as the most effective at cradling your body and providing contoured support as you sink into your mattress.

The one caveat is that the Lucid may not be as long lasting as more expensive toppers. Some might find that the Lucid flattens in some spots and not in others, or that it begins to tear after a short amount of time. Fortunately, the company offers a 3-year warranty on their product, so if you should experience any issues you can reach out to them and they’ll resolve your issue or provide a replacement.

Overall, the Lucid Bamboo Charcoal Memory Foam Mattress Topper provides the supportive, contouring sleep experience that you’d expect from a memory foam topper with an odor absorbing, moisture regulating infusion of bamboo charcoal for the ultimate in nighttime comfort.

Key Features
  • Choose between 2, 3 or 4 inches
  • Bamboo charcoal-infused memory foam
  • Ventilated design provides for maximum breathability
Specifications
  • Dimensions: 59" x 79" x 3.9" queen
  • Weight: 22.1 pounds
  • Material: Memory foam infused with bamboo charcoal
  • Brand: Lucid
  • Warranty: 3 years
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Ca King
Pros
  • Bamboo charcoal absorbs odors and regulates moisture
  • Ventilated design provides cooling to warm memory foam
  • Contouring and supportive
Cons
  • May flatten in spots
  • Fragile, easily damaged

If you’re allergy prone or feel hot during the night, and don’t require contouring or additional support for your mattress, you may want to consider the Sopat Extra Thick Mattress Topper. The Sopat is a down alternative product, and it’s primarily designed to add softness to an overly firm mattress.

The Sopat’s advantage comes from its extra filling— 50 percent more then its competitors' products. The filling is a microfiber material and is enclosed in a 400 thread count 100 percent cotton cover for maximum airflow and breathability. The Sopat is also made with a double-border construction, which is designed to evenly distribute its fill, so you don’t end up with a topper that has a mixture of lumpy and flat spots.

While the cooling softness that the Sopat provides is welcome, some might discover it becomes deflated over time and has to be re-fluffed often. However, bear in mind that when purchasing down or down alternative products, these are not really designed to provide support and loft to a mattress but are used more for that “sleeping on a cloud” feeling.

So, if you’re leaning more towards softness over support, the Sopat Extra Thick Mattress Topper may be an option worth considering.

Key Features
  • 400 thread count cotton cover
  • Microfiber fill
  • Double border pillow top construction
Specifications
  • Dimensions: 60"x 80"x 18"
  • Weight: 9.15 pounds
  • Material: Microfiber/Cotton
  • Brand: Sopat
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Full, Queen, King, Ca King
Pros
  • High thread count cotton cover
  • Double border pillowtop construction allows for even fill distribution
  • Cooling and breathable
Cons
  • Limited support
  • No contouring ability

If you love the support that memory foam provides but hate the hot, sweaty feeling as you sleep, a gel/foam hybrid may be the right choice for you. The Milemont combines plush memory foam that conforms to and hugs your body, surrounded by the cooling, temperature regulation of gel beads.

The Milemont is 2 inches thick (there's also a 3-inch option) and provides supportive, even weight distribution to aid in proper spinal alignment and elimination of pressure points.

The memory foam in the Milemont is high-quality CertiPUR US-certified, which tests quality and durability, and requires that no harmful substances be used in the product’s manufacturing process. This eliminates the possibility of your mattress topper releasing harmful, off-gassing chemicals that may be hazardous to you or your family.

Since the mattress topper arrives to you in compressed form, the manufacturer recommends allowing 24 hours for it to fully settle and decompress before sleeping on it. While this may be a negative for some, it’s also good to know that this 24 hour “air-out” period seems to eliminate all traces of plastic or chemically odor.

Other downsides to the Milemont are standard complaints that come from owning a memory foam mattress topper, including the lack of breathability or giving off a “hot feeling” as you sleep, as well as its propensity to tear and crack. Although the Milemont is infused with cooling gel, these beads can only go so far to compete with memory foam’s tendency towards heat retention.

However, if you find that your mattress is lacking in support, but also feels hard, the Milemont seems to eliminate both of these concerns by providing your bed with a soft, yet firm and supportive, feeling.

Key Features
  • Memory foam/gel hybrid mattress
  • 2-inch or 3-inch choice of thickness
  • Softness with support
Specifications
  • Dimensions: 80" x 60" queen
  • Weight: 5.6 pounds
  • Material: Gel/Memory Foam
  • Brand: Milemont
  • Warranty: 10 years
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Full, Queen, King
Pros
  • Infused gel beads to aid in cooling
  • Provides contouring and body alignment
  • Combines softness with support even for old mattresses
Cons
  • Tendency to feel hot despite gel beads
  • Must wait 24 hours before use
  • Slight odor upon arrival

The Duck & Goose Co. Plush Hotel Quality Mattress Topper is a high-end memory foam alternative. The topper features 100 percent microfiber fill generously stuffed inside an antimicrobial cover. The Duck & Goose topper is designed to provide a soft, cool, cloudlike feeling to a hard and overly firm mattress.

Thoughtful details have gone into constructing the Duck & Goose mattress topper, including square shaped stitching to ensure even fill distribution, and a channel weave designed to transport heat and moisture away from the body.

Like other non-memory foam mattress toppers, the Duck & Goose allows for maximum airflow and breathability in your bedding and is perfect for those who feel hot during the night. However, the Duck & Goose won’t provide any type of contouring or support, and it doesn’t absorb motion from a restless sleeping partner.

Because of the compressed state that the product is shipped in, some might find their mattress topper comes flat upon receiving and unpacking the box. In order to re-fluff the topper back to its original loft, the company recommends placing it in the dryer on low heat, and it will plump back to normal form.

It’s also important to note that although this product is machine washable, it is not recommended to launder in a top-load machine, due to fact that the agitator may damage or tear the topper’s fibers. However, despite these drawbacks, the Duck & Goose mattress topper is known for its overall softness and comfort it provided. Therefore, if you are looking to add softness and breathability to your bed, the Duck & Goose mattress topper may be the perfect fit.

Key Features
  • Overfilled with down alternative microfiber
  • 2-inch thickness
  • Anchor bands provide a secure fit
  • Hypoallergenic and antibacterial
Specifications
  • Dimensions: 60 x 80 x 2 inches
  • Weight: 11.15 pounds
  • Material: Microfiber
  • Brand: Duck & Goose Co
  • Warranty: 10 years
  • Sizes Available: Twin, Full, Queen, King
Pros
  • Breathable material remains cool
  • Hypoallergenic for allergy sufferers
  • Machine washable
  • No chemical odor
Cons
  • Needs fluffing up in dryer prior to use
  • Not suitable for top-loading washing machines

Let’s face it: mattresses take a lot of abuse. From the occasional jumping kid to our all too frequent tendency to “plop into the bed,” coupled with nightly use, the mattress is like the bumper on a car and often bears the brunt of many different burdens.

But even with all the wear and tear we inflict on them, we expect our mattresses to hold strong, and to feel as though we’re sleeping on a cloud. Whether or not this is a reasonable expectation is debatable, but what’s not open for argument is the expense of replacing them, which hovers around the $1000 range for a good-quality queen mattress.

Even when they haven’t been subjected to rowdy children or stress-induced plops into bed, mattresses tend to sag and droop as they age (just as we do!) and become heavy from the buildup of sweat and skin cells that we shed nightly. This leaves us with a mattress that feels lumpy, unsupportive, and saggy. And unlike other factors, nighttime sweating and skin shedding is basically unavoidable.

Despite the best of intentions, you may be dismayed to discover that, after only a few years, your mattress has not held up nearly as well as you’d expected. And whether your budget doesn’t allow for it, or you simply refuse to spring for a new mattress based on principle, you’ll want to consider an alternative in order to improve your quality of sleep.

Enter the mattress topper. A high-quality topper can improve your overall sleep experience by providing needed support to a sagging bed or softening out an overly firm mattress. A good topper can also prolong the life of your mattress, by placing a barrier between your sweaty skin cells (see above) and your bed.

But upon searching for the best mattress topper, you may find yourself bombarded with fishy-sounding claims and promises. Companies all praise their mattress topper’s material as superior to the next.

Mattress toppers are made from a variety of materials, each designed with their own specific purpose and benefits. However, as is the case with most everything you buy, each also has its own limitations and drawbacks. For instance, memory foam tends to be supportive and contouring, but is also hot and prone to cracking. Latex combines durability with softness and support but is very heavy and bulky. And down and down-alternative products provide a cooling and soothing sleep experience, but offer limited back support, and don’t stop the transfer of motion when your partner tosses and turns.

With so many options available to you, we’ve compiled a list of our picks for best mattress topper, based on a variety of material types and our research. We hope this list helps you rest easy, knowing you’ll be purchasing the right mattress topper for your specific needs.

Resources — Tuck, Sleep Advisor

Share this Buyers Guide

Popular in Home